Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Wing Chun or Wing Tsun?
Collapse
X
-
Registered User
- Sep 2006
- 103
-
Take care out there and keep
me
www.tjwingchun.co.uk
sifu
www.kwokwingchun.com
sigung
www.ipchun.org
my family
www.ipfamilywingchun.com
questions are how we grow, answers how we develop, knowledge is power.
Originally posted by jubaji View PostOh great, another stupid closet case...
Comment
-
Registered User
- Sep 2006
- 103
-
Take care out there and keep
me
www.tjwingchun.co.uk
sifu
www.kwokwingchun.com
sigung
www.ipchun.org
my family
www.ipfamilywingchun.com
questions are how we grow, answers how we develop, knowledge is power.
Originally posted by gregimotis View PostROFL!
This last few posts > the whole rest of this thread.
Since I started coming into forums a few years ago I have been amazed at the hatred of Wing Chun, I can understand the bitterness of Thai Bri as he had contact with immature instructors and I admnit when I started in 1983 my classes were not that indepth, but like anything as we grow we develop and so I only defend what I teach now, but make no apologies for going through the learning curve that any teacher goes through.
Now to the whole point of this reply, if you cannot laugh at yourself and your art then you should give up before you turn into a bitter and wrinkled old prune, sorry Thai Bri not getting at you again, lol.
Comment
-
As it has been mentioned before, Thai Bri has based his wing chun experience on three teachers who taught the art too traditionally for him.
There are varying versions of wing chun out there from school to school
Some want to train very traditionally which involves less fighting and more about structure.
A lot of other federations (Kamon, James Sinclair, Alan Orr, for example) concentrate more on the practicalites of wing chun. If you use wing chun right and train against resisting opponents (that Jubajii and Thai Bri say we don't do), then it is devastating.
I have been to various schools and I always give them a chance. If a school doesn't train fighting then so be it. It isn't for me, but I respect the school's training methods, as long as it doesn't claim to be self defence or a fighting martial art
Comment
-
As it has been mentioned before, Thai Bri has based his wing chun experience on three teachers who taught the art too traditionally for him.
There are varying versions of wing chun out there from school to school
Some want to train very traditionally which involves less fighting and more about structure.
A lot of other federations (Kamon, James Sinclair, Alan Orr, for example) concentrate more on the practicalites of wing chun. If you use wing chun right and train against resisting opponents (that Jubajii and Thai Bri say we don't do), then it is devastating.
I have been to various schools and I always give them a chance. If a school doesn't train fighting then so be it. It isn't for me, but I respect the school's training methods, as long as it doesn't claim to be self defence or a fighting martial art
As for humour, I think humour has a limit. People have a right to be offended if someone insults the thing they love. Just as if someone had insulted a friend or lover........
Comment
-
Red Rum - just how many times do I have to remind you that the "Wing Chun2 in the Kamon videos is Kick Boxing?
Durrrrr.
Let TJ take a look at the site and see all the clips. Then he can tell us which ones are Wing Chun, and which ones are not.
I don't even have a problem with Kamon doing this. But to see you keep referring to this MMA type hotch potch as Wing Chun is ridiculous.
While your at it, as hom how much sense it makes to punch bare walls with your bare hands as hard as you can.
Comment
-
Registered User
- Sep 2006
- 103
-
Take care out there and keep
me
www.tjwingchun.co.uk
sifu
www.kwokwingchun.com
sigung
www.ipchun.org
my family
www.ipfamilywingchun.com
questions are how we grow, answers how we develop, knowledge is power.
-
Originally posted by Red Rum View PostNot at all. I sparred (chi sao) with my mate last night who is a blue belt in Gracie Barra.
Better yet...put a knife in each one of your hands...and that way both of your uni-dimensional asses lose.
Comment
Comment