Is Panantuken part of Kali

[Warrior189]

I want to know if Panantuken, Dumog n Pananjakma is part of Kali teachings or is it a art of its own?

[bigred389]

I'd say they're part of kali teachings.

[Limbas]

Panantukan and panadyakan as I understood 'em are generic terms for boxing and kicking respectively but are inherent in every filipino weapon art.

[danjuandesiga]

YES. It is a part of Kali and Yes, it can stand on it's own.

[Warrior189]

Just want to make sure ok. If someone comes up to me and ask what martial arts I do. My answer can be Panantuken, Dumog n Pananjakma right.

[William]

Just say FFA's (Filipino Fighting Arts).



William

[bahotae]

No they're not! There may be some systems that teach it a whole. But in reality they are not often taught as a whole. You cannot even find a Panantukan master in the Philippines. Most Arnis instructors like to say they practice dumog but in reality they do Judo or Jiujitsu which is common to most arnis instructors. Its hard to find a dumog practitioner in the Philippines but there seems to be plenty in the States same with Panantukan.

I wonder why?

Someone already answered this question in another thread.

[HybriDD1]

>>>> It's hard to find a Dumog practicioner in the Philippines

When I first started practicing JKDC I really gravitated to the grappling/dumog techniques. Around this same time my Father-in-law (who is Filipino) took a vacation to the Philippines (Luzon). Anyway he has a nephew who is an officer in the PNP and is an Arnis teacher/champion. He invited my Father-in-law to one of their training sessions to watch. My FIL asks the officers if they practiced any Dumog(since he had seen me practicing it in the States). The Filipinos had NO CLUE what he was talking about, had never heard of Dumog, seen it, nor did they no anyone in Southern/Central Luzon who knew of the term. I'm guessing Dumog is not a term used in Tagalog nor are the techniques known(or called that anyway) in Luzon. Kinda funny.

[thekuntawman]

you got to be kidding guys!

its 2006 how many times have this question been answered?

it is part of american FMA. it is part of FILIPINO FMA when the filipino teacher want american students.

[McDojoJKD]

OH LAWD here we go with the secret filipino BJJ and biting techniques. I wish you all would quit this stuff. As a matter of fact stop paying all that tuition for this type of nonsense....

[tim_stl]

[QUOTE=HybriDD1;238266I'm guessing Dumog is not a term used in Tagalog nor are the techniques known(or called that anyway) in Luzon. Kinda funny.[/QUOTE]

dumog is a visayan/cebuano word. it just means wrestling. buno is the tagalog translation.



tim